Despite Trump executive order, majority still opposes attempts to silence & defund campus critics of Israeli human rights abuses - 12/18/2019
IRmep Poll:
“President Trump issued an executive order allowing
him to cut federal funds to colleges and
universities where students and/or faculty protest
Israeli human rights abuses. Do you support or
oppose the executive order?” Source:
IRmep representative poll of 2,017 American
adults through
Google Surveys on December 16-18. Answer order
randomly reversed.
The Israeli government and many of Israel’s U.S. lobbying organizations strongly support the ongoing annexation of Palestinian lands and expulsion of their native inhabitants. They are irritated by the Palestinian Civil Society Call for the international boycott, divestment and sanctions of Israel until there is a just settlement of the Israel Palestine question. However, rather than work for that solution, Israel and its lobby have been attempting to stifle and defund forums where robust free speech and civil action are taking place in support of Palestinian human rights. On December 11, 2019 President Trump signed an executive order targeting colleges and universities. Though framed as a measure to “combat anti-Semitism” and credulously reported as such by major media outlets, the order advances a punitive agenda to silence and cow human rights activism and 1st Amendment advocates. The Israel lobby utterly failed to persuade Congress to legislate such measures into law. Lawsuits filed by Kenneth Marcus before he became the Trump administration’s Assistant Secretary for Civil Rights were also mostly a flop. In November of 2017 the American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC), American Jewish Committee (AJC), Simon Wiesenthal Center and the Anti-Defamation League (ADL) jointly lobbied the House Judiciary Committee for a floor vote on a bill to withhold funding from colleges and universities under Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. Testimony revealed their target—just like the Trump Executive Order—was robust speech and civic action taking place on college and university campuses. The joint lobbying was a power move, as Rabbi Abraham Cooper of the Simon Wiesenthal Center testified. “You have the wall-to-wall leadership of the American Jewish community here…we need to move the ball forward…we hope you’ll send this to the floor of the house for further deliberation.” But despite the pressure, the legislation failed under withering criticism. Professor Barry Trachtenberg, Jewish History Chair at Wake Forest University, who also testified before the committee cast a harsh light on the drivers behind the legislation. “It is increasingly common to hear reports that a new anti-Semitism threatens to endanger students on a scale not seen since the Second World War and the Holocaust…however, they are motivated less by an actual threat faced by American or world Jewry, than they are part of a persistent campaign to thwart debates, scholarly research, and political action that is critical of the state of Israel.” Many other experts also revealed how the legislation was clearly unconstitutional. Nearly 61 percent of Americans polled opposed the law. A similarly draconian bill targeting American businesses seeking government contracts also floundered, with 74.9 percent of Americans opposed. Under the Trump administration, executive action is supplanting congressional legislation. On November 18 the U.S. Secretary of State reversed a 1978 State Department legal opinion stating that Israeli settlements were “inconsistent with international law.” Americans don’t share that view. This most recent announcement is yet another Israel lobby-powered Trump administration attempt to end-run overwhelming American consensus, the courts and the will of congress to mount attacks on conscientious critics, rather than taking on the more difficult work toward just solutions to the Israel Palestine question. "The Israel Lobby Enters State Government" - Free on Web & YouTube, also available in Paperback & Audible - 12/09/2019Israel lobby graft and corruption inside Virginia's state government is rampant. Could it happen to your state?
The
Israel Lobby Enters State Government chronicles
the formation, rise and secret activities of the
Virginia Israel Advisory Board (VIAB). While other books
have focused on the Israel lobby’s influence over the
federal government and U.S. foreign policy, there has
been little research on Israel lobbying at the state
level. Using sensitive documents acquired under
Virginia’s sunshine law, this book argues that in
Virginia the Israel lobby is no longer on the outside,
but has now entered state government. The Virginia
Israel Advisory Board (VIAB) is presently the only state
government entity in the U.S. focused entirely on
bringing corporations in from a single foreign country.
The book explores how millions in taxpayer and other
state funds are quietly being diverted from multiple
sources to establish profitable Israeli companies in
Virginia. The corporations are involved in military
contracting, food and beverage manufacturing, energy
generation, waste management and aquaculture. The author
analyzes how VIAB projects displace workers and put
home-grown market leaders out of business. By unmasking
Israeli businesses launching operations that VIAB
protects under code-names and opaque shell companies to
secretly transact business in Virginia, the book exposes
the reason behind some of the secrecy—their extensive
business dealings in territory illegally occupied by
Israel. Only 19.7% of Americans share State Dept. view that international law doesn't apply to Israeli settlements - 11/27/2019
IRmep Poll: “International law SHOULD APPLY to Israel’s
military occupation & colonization of the West Bank,
Golan Heights, E. Jerusalem and displacement of their
indigenous populations. Do you Disagree or Agree?” Fraud at Israeli Military Contractor Oran Safety Glass: Plunge in DOD contracts incentivizes more war, jeopardizes Greensville County - 11/25/2019..The fact that particular contracts are for MRAPs is a government secret. So, the five contracts cannot be identified from within publicly accessible listings of payments that have exact dollar amounts related to contracts awarded to OSG. However, military contract databases do reveal that in 2016, in an uncharacteristic move, OSG repaid the US government $4.7 million. It is not known if any American military personnel whose lives depended on non-compliant OSG armor, ever paid the ultimate price over Oran’s contracting malfeasance.
2009-2018
annual OSG revenue from
U.S. government military
contracts in steep
decline ($ million)
From the perspective of US taxpayers and residents of
Greensville County in Virginia, there are a number of
problems with the way OSG does business that are unique
to its status as a recipient of massive amounts of
funding orchestrated by the Virginia Israel Advisory
Board. VIAB is presently the only taxpayer funded state
government Israel export promotion council in the US
Some VIAB board members hold equity stakes and positions
as corporate officers in Israeli companies or joint
ventures seeking to start operations in Virginia. Others
are long-term officers of the American Israel Public
Affairs Committee (AIPAC) and other national Israel
affinity and lobbying organizations. "Transcending the Israel Lobby at Home and Abroad" Conference, May 29, 2020, Washington, DCWASHINGTON, Nov. 20, 2019 /PRNewswire/ -- This annual conference at the National Press Club in Washington, DC explores the latest research, innovations and tactics for countering the Israel lobby's damaging policies in the U.S. and around the globe.
This conference has grown to
become one of the largest educational events
in Washington, attracting nearly 1,000 participants,
including activists, students, educators, alternative
news media, nonprofits, the international community and
the private sector. It also provides an excellent
opportunity for face-to-face networking.
2020 Themes:
1. How
Americans are effectively working to
overcome Israel lobby demands to violate international
law, undermine freedom of speech, reward Israeli
militarism and denigrate peaceful Palestinian
aspirations.
2. How
voters this election year can both support and field
politicians, and keep them from succumbing to the
lobby's coordinated campaign contributions and constant
pressure for fealty.
3. Exploring
important grassroots legislative and legal battles won
by peace and justice allies in 2019-2020, how they did
it, and how you can, too.
4. The
key differences between Jewish establishment Zionism and
Christian Zionism, and common misunderstandings.
5. How
to implement "non-Israel-centric" regional strategies to
eliminate the crippling human and financial costs of
unending wars.
Conference attendees receive a box lunch and invitation
to a special networking reception.
For the first time ever, we are opening up our
traditional "speakers dinner" as a public fund-raising
gala! Join keynoters, speakers and a surprising lineup
of entertainers for a delicious, educational and
uplifting gathering the evening before the conference,
on May 28! All gala proceeds go toward covering
conference expenses!
Get your discounted tickets now through Eventbrite. Make
a tax-deductible
contribution to cover conference costs
and student travel stipends.
For more information, speaker updates and student
tickets, visit the conference website at https://IsraelLobbyCon.org IsraelLobbyCon is solely sponsored by the American Educational Trust, publisher of the Washington Report on Middle East Affairs, and the Institute for Research: Middle Eastern Policy (IRmep).
Confronting the “Deal of the Century” from a US perspective - 11/09/2019
IRmep presentation at the Palestine Center’s annual conference. It covered how the Gallup Organization’s misleading polls about U.S. "sympathy" for Israel would have been deployed to falsely claim Americans support the Trump-Kushner-Friedman-Greenblatt Middle East "Deal of the Century," much like they have been used by the Congressional Research Service to insinuate Americans support massive U.S. foreign assistance to Israel. How Gallup was confronted until it finally admitted its bellwether poll was biased. What most Americans really think about the principle of the economic "Deal of the Century." How Virginians view their own mini "Deal of the Century" advanced by Israel partisans placed inside their own state government by Israel lobby campaign contributions. The relative policy influence potential of the public opinions of the American majority vs economic elites and interest groups, in this case the U.S. Israel advocacy ecosystem. Slides (PDF) Audio (MP3) Video (YouTube) Are Israeli Settlers Secretly Installing Solar Panels at Virginia Public Schools? -November-December 2019AN ISRAELI REAL ESTATE and solar energy giant secretly owns a U.S. solar energy developer and is building solar farms across the state of Virginia. Because it is using shell companies as fronts, nobody but a handful of corporate insiders and members of the state Virginia Israel Advisory Board appear to know the identity of the true beneficial foreign owners in Israel.
None of the customers at public schools, data centers and other organizations now signing 25- and 30-year contracts exchanging valuable rooftops and land for solar farms seem to know about the secret Israeli company’s extensive business activities in Palestinian and Syrian territories illegally occupied by Israel. Some customers are signing deals they don’t fully understand, and their signed contracts are financially disadvantageous to the point of being predatory. Schools in particular believe they are entering into deals with a young, Virginia-based, pet-friendly and social-media-savvy startup that just wants to make the world a bit more sustainable. But the story is much more complex, because stealth and misdirection is everywhere. Read more at the Washington Report on Middle East Affairs The Israel Lobby Enters State Government - Author book chat - 11/04/2019
New Book! The Israel Lobby Enters State Government: Rise of the Virginia Israel Advisory Board - 10/29/2019This book chronicles the formation, rise and secret activities of the Virginia Israel Advisory Board (VIAB). While other books have focused on the Israel lobby’s influence over the federal government and U.S. foreign policy, there has been little research on Israel lobbying at the state level. Using sensitive documents acquired under Virginia’s sunshine law, this book argues that in Virginia the Israel lobby is no longer on the outside, but has now entered state government. The Virginia Israel Advisory Board (VIAB) is presently the only state government entity in the U.S. focused entirely on bringing corporations in from a single foreign country. The book explores how millions in taxpayer and other state funds are quietly being diverted from multiple sources to establish profitable Israeli companies in Virginia. The corporations are involved in military contracting, food and beverage manufacturing, energy generation, waste management and aquaculture. The author analyzes how VIAB projects displace workers and put home-grown market leaders out of business. By unmasking Israeli businesses launching operations that VIAB protects under code-names and opaque shell companies to secretly transact business in Virginia, the book exposes the reason behind some of the secrecy—their extensive business dealings in territory illegally occupied by Israel. The author delves into the establishment of VIAB by the state’s Jewish federations, and their continued involvement as VIAB board members, as well as their attempts to rewrite school textbooks and quash through new laws speech critical of Israel. Smith exposes who is running VIAB, how they leverage political campaign contributions, and the bankruptcy of VIAB’s many claims that their dealings are advancing the prosperity of working Virginians—as opposed to Israeli companies and VIAB insiders. He probes the true nature of the Virginia Israel Advisory Board and the future threat if similar Israel lobby entities proliferate within other state governments. Buy at Middle East Books & More or Amazon.com US Should Support Israeli Land Grabs Say AIPAC Think-Tankers - American cash for weapons and Israeli settler relocation - 9/25/2019...If the delivery vehicle of Be Strong and of Good Courage is a collection of enticing founding father bios, what is the payload? It appears in the final chapter. As to be expected, it is an appeal for additional withdrawals from the U.S. Treasury Department and already dangerously overdrawn bank account of US international standing. The book proposes that in exchange for ending settlement construction east of the separation wall Israel built, much of it on Palestinian land, and a halt in Jewish real estate acquisition within Arab neighborhoods in occupied East Jerusalem, Israeli settlers would move to locations within Israel or to lands that will soon become part of Israel. Israel will of course maintain the right to conduct military operations east of the wall, but would abide Palestinian development of Dead Sea tourism and mineral industries.
The book recommends that the US Israel lobby, which partly owes its existence, identity and power to Israel, do what it does best: extract what Israel needs from America to realize Israel’s national ambitions. The US should provide "cash" to relocate settlers to areas within the Green Line or to newly annexed West Bank settlement blocs. The US should then block any UN resolutions opposed to unilateral Israeli annexations, and "work with the Europeans and others to gain their public support for Israel’s unilateral moves to ensure separation." The US should also fight the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions (BDS) movement and publicly criticize European and Arab leaders who fail to wholeheartedly approve. Of course, Israel’s annexations will create new security challenges, so the US should also promptly increase Israel’s "qualitative military edge..." Full Report at Antiwar.com Related video at YouTube. Something's Fishy About AquaMaof's "Project Jonah" in Virginia - Washington Report on Middle East Affairs Special Report October/November
Special WRMEA report. Israel Lobby Archive VFOIA documents Podcast interview Interview page Poll: Americans oppose Israel lobby junkets, but longstanding capture of the IRS perpetuates conduits like AIEF - 08/15/2019
"...A
close tie to the IRS is
also the story of how
the American Israel
Education Foundation
came into being.
Although AEIF claims it
"was created in 1990" it
actually formed in
September of 1988 and
applied for tax-exempt
status in April of 1989.
AIEF’s application
presented tightly argued
reasons for why it
should immediately – and
forever after – be
affirmed by the IRS as a
tax-exempt educational
charity. The IRS
delivered a
determination letter to
AEIF in just four
months. There was little
chance for a conditional
five year "probationary"
period which is common
for new entities with no
track record. That is
because of AIEF’s
October 11, 1988 (PDF)
seven-page justification
for why it should
receive tax exempt
status. It was signed
off and most likely
entirely drafted by
Milton Cherny who had
worked as the technical
advisor in charge of tax
exempt rulings at the
IRS National Office in
Washington up until
departing the IRS in
September of 1988 to
"begin" work on AIEF’s
submission. “Visit your district, not Israel” 65.7 percent of Americans tell Congress - 08/12/2019IRmep Poll: 41 House Democrats are now visiting Israel during the Congressional recess on a trip funded by a tax-exempt pro-Israel charity linked to the U.S. Israel lobby group AIPAC. Source: IRmep representative poll of 2,000 American adults through Google Surveys on August 8-10. Most American adults of voting age believe representatives should visit their congressional districts rather than go to Israel according to a new poll. IRmep Polls surveyed 2,000 American adults about where they believed congressional reps should go during recess. Junkets to Israel funded by an entity housed within the American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC), a domestically registered lobby and a small number of other Israel lobby groups account for a third of all privately funded congressional trips with an international destination. Members of Congress participating in the trips are accompanied by AIPAC employees. According to a leaked briefing booklet the trips are designed to present Israel as a militarily vulnerable and valuable ally deserving massive U.S. foreign aid. The program does not include any discussion of Israel’s nuclear weapons program, military occupation of Palestinian territories or meaningful visits with Palestinians representative of those displaced by Israel’s creation. More at IRmep Polls.
The IRS supports illegal settlements, but doesn't want to talk about it. 8/1/2019
Grant F. Smith, director of research at IRmep, exposes the IRS's long history of aiding and abetting billions of dollars of U.S. charitable contributions flowing through tax-exempt charities into illegal West Bank settlements during a live broadcast with the IRS Taxpayer Advocate. YouTube Audio 68% of Americans would reject Trump’s Mideast “Deal of the Century” August-September 2019
ON JUNE 25-26 JARED
KUSHNER orchestrated the
“Peace to Prosperity”
economic workshop in
Bahrain. Kushner is
President Donald Trump’s
son-in-law and his
senior adviser on
negotiating a Middle
East peace. The White
House plan closely
follows a strategy
proposed by the late
Israeli President Shimon
Peres. Peres assumed
integration of the
Middle East through
widescale economic
development would induce
all parties to
successfully tackle more
difficult final status
issues of borders,
territory and refugees
at a later time. Only 5.7% of Americans say Israel is the top meddler in US elections: Skepticism about lobbying for foreign government "relationships"- 07/15/2019
Mainstream news coverage of foreign government influence
on U.S. elections has been extensive since allegations
first surfaced about Russian interference in the 2016
presidential race. According to a new poll, a solid
60.0% majority of Americans now believe Russia is the
single top meddler in US elections, followed by China
(16.4%) and the United Kingdom (7.1%). IRmep Poll: Which country do you believe meddles the most in US elections? Full report at Antiwar.com. See more polls at IRmep Polls.
Did Israel pull the U.S. out of compliance with
the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty?
|
Member of Congress Privately Funded Foreign Trips – 2014-2018 | ||
Source: Travel Reports from the office of Clerk |
The vast majority of Israel trips are funded by the American Israel Education Foundation which raises tax-exempt contributions from pro-Israel donors and Jewish federations. They typically last eight days and cost $10,000. AEIF is a corporation created in 1988 by the domestically-registered lobbying group AIPAC, the American Israel Public Affairs Committee. In 2009 66% of AEIF’s board was comprised of AIPAC directors. Since AIEF is merely a lobbying funding conduit with no employees, whenever members of Congress travel to Israel, they are accompanied instead by staffers from AIPAC. In 2017 AIEF reported raising $60 million in revenue and expending $57 million. Another sole-purpose entity set up by AIPAC in 1984 is the Washington Institute for Near East Policy which works to portray policies favored by the Israeli government as being in the American interest.
Full report at Antiwar.com
Speakers at "The Israel Lobby & American Policy Conference 2019 " on March 22
WASHINGTON, Feb. 27, 2019 /PRNewswire-USNewswire/ --
“The Israel Lobby & American Policy 2019 Conference”
takes place all day on March 22 at the National Press
Club in Washington, DC, and will feature the following
speakers:
Susan Abulhawa
is a Palestinian novelist, poet, essayist and founder of
Playgrounds for
Palestine. Her keynote speech topic is
“Israel: More than just Apartheid.”
Ali Abunimah
is a journalist and the co-founder and executive
director of the widely acclaimed
The Electronic
Intifada. He will discuss “What does a
censored undercover news investigation reveal about the
Israel lobby in America?”
Saqib Ali served as a
Democratic Party member of the Maryland House of
Delegates and will address “Why I’m suing Maryland to
protect my constitutional right to boycott Israel.”
Kathy Drinkard
is a retired teacher and elementary
school counselor, and pro-Palestine activist who will
address “How the Virginia Coalition for Human Rights
(VCHR) is preventing Israel affinity organizations from
politicizing K-12 textbooks.”
Walter Hixson is a
distinguished professor of history at the University of
Akron. He will discuss key findings from his forthcoming
book, Israel’s Armor: The Israel Lobby and the First
Generation of the Palestine Conflict.
Martin F. McMahon
is the plaintiffs’ attorney in the
landmark legal action against Israeli settlers and their
American financiers. He explains what follows his
Palestinian and American plaintiffs’ recent legal
victory in the DC Court of Appeals.
James Metz co-founded
Richmonders for Peace in Israel-Palestine and will speak
about “Why VCHR is taking on the Virginia Israel
Advisory Board.”
James North
is a contributing editor at Mondoweiss
and will examine “How The New York Times rigs
news on Israel Palestine.”
Paul Noursi
is co-director of the Virginia
Coalition for Human Rights (VCHR) and will discuss “What
is the VCHR?”
Brad Parker is senior
adviser, policy and advocacy, at Defense for Children
International and will cover “What lessons can activists
take away from the Promoting Human Rights by Ending
Israeli Military Detention of Palestinian Children Act?”
Grant Smith is research
director at IRmep and will speak about “U.S. foreign aid
and the Israeli nuclear weapons program.”
Register online
at
https://IsraelLobbyandAmericanPolicy.org
or
https://israellobbycon.eventbrite.com
Students may
apply for free tickets and stipends at
https://israellobbyandamericanpolicy.org/Students_Stipends/
News media may
apply for press credentials at
https://israellobbyandamericanpolicy.org/Press_credentials/
Ticketholders
can attend the main program, ideas fair, receive a box
lunch and an invitation to the post-conference
reception!
IsraelLobbyCon
is solely sponsored by the American Educational Trust,
publisher of the
Washington Report
on Middle East Affairs, and the
Institute for Research: Middle Eastern Policy (IRmep).
IRmep Poll: 41% want members of the U.S Congress to visit Palestinian territories - 02/26/2019
When asked, 41.2% of American adults recently polled said members making visits to Israel should also visit “territories where Palestinians expelled during Israel’s creation live.”
Question: Should members of the US Congress taking educational trips to Israel also visit the territories where Palestinians expelled during Israel's creation live?
Source: IRmep representative poll of 1,014 American adults through Google Surveys on February 19-23 with a root mean square of 4.7%.
Though not as statistically relevant as the overall poll results, demographic filtering reveals younger and older adults are generally more supportive of Palestinian territory visits. In the 18-24 category, 45.7% favored such visits while in the 25-34 age group 46% were supportive of Congress members visiting Palestine. 55-64 year-olds and 65+ category also had higher favorability to the idea. Other IRmep Polls
Poll: 75% of Americans Oppose Outlawing Boycotts of Israel - Some fighting back over freedom of speech - 02/12/2019
New legislation passed
in the Senate seeks to
legalize the right of
individual state
governments to force
American companies to
certify they won’t
engage in economic
boycotts of Israel as a
condition for receiving
government contracts.
The "Combating BDS Act
of 2019" is embedded as
Title IV within the
‘‘Strengthening
America’s Security in
the Middle East Act of
2019’’ (S.1). If signed
into law, S.1 would
allow states to withhold
government funding from
entities unwilling to
certify they will not
boycott Israel. Most
existing state anti-BDS
measures require pledge
forms that contractors
must sign as a condition
for winning or renewing
contracts
But only 22.5% of
American adults favor
anti-boycott measures. A
new representative IRmep
poll conducted through
Google Surveys finds
that 74.9% of Americans
oppose forcing
government contractors
to forswear boycotts.
Question:
Should Congress force
American businesses
seeking government
contracts to first sign
a pledge that they won’t
boycott Israel for its
human rights record and
military occupation?
Full report at Antiwar.com Polling data IRmep poll page
What Israel lobbyists have been getting away with for years - 2/11/2019
Flashpoints host Dennis Bernstein and IRmep's Grant F. Smith discuss the Twitter and media frenzy unleashed by Minnesota representative Ilhan Omar's brief tweet about the Israel lobby and money. How did AIPAC reconstitute after the Department of Justice ordered it to register as an Israeli foreign agent? How does AIPAC wield power and influence? Why does establishment media do such a poor job reporting on Israel Palestine and the lobby? What cracks are starting to appear?
IRmep Lawsuit: US nuclear "policy substitution" for Israel undermines NPT, AECA and bilks US taxpayers - 1/25/2019
On January 17, IRmep
filed a 59-page brief (PDF
HTML) in a lawsuit
demanding release of a
series of secret
presidential letters
promising not to force
Israel to sign the
Treaty on the
Non-Proliferation of
Nuclear Weapons (NPT) or
publicly discuss
Israel's nuclear weapons
program.
The brief contextualizes
a formerly top-secret
1969 cross-agency study
about what U.S. policy
toward Israel’s nuclear
weapons should be.
Unanimous consensus
between the Departments
of Defense, State and
intelligence community
was that Israel should
be compelled to sign the
NPT in order to be
allowed to purchase
conventional U.S.
military weapons.
Government agencies
correctly believed that
if Israel was allowed to
possess nuclear weapons
there would never be
peace in the Middle
East. National security
adviser Henry Kissinger
also grudgingly revealed
intelligence in the
summary that Israelis
had stolen U.S.
government nuclear
material to build their
arsenal atomic weapons.
(1969 NSC papers on the
Israeli nuclear weapons
program filed as Exhibit
A
PDF)
Going against the
consensus advice, on
September 26, 1969,
President Nixon adopted
the Israeli policy of
“ambiguity” (never
confirming or denying
Israel’s nuclear weapons
program) in a meeting
with Israeli Prime
Minister Golda Meir. US
presidents through
Donald Trump have
continued the Israeli
"ambiguity" policy in a
series of letters
written under intense lobbying
by the Israeli
government.
According to the IRmep
legal filing, this
policy has perpetuated a
$222.8 billion dollar
fraud against U.S.
taxpayers through
non-enforcement of
Arms Export Control Act
bans on U.S. foreign
aid—absent specific
waivers—to known foreign
nuclear powers that have
not signed the NPT. The
IRmep filing also
debunks a series of
assertions and
disinformation filed in
an affidavit by the
National Security
Council
On January 18, 2019 the
Department of Justice
filed a motion to
indefinitely stop the
lawsuit from proceeding
until the end of the
government shutdown,
citing lack of funds to
mount a legal defense. (PDF)
Listen to a discussion
about next steps for
this critical IRmep
litigation and
our other lawsuits
on the Scott Horton Show
(MP3).
IRmep Stream: Evidence of Israel's undue influence: Joshua Geltzer, former Obama NSC, asked to respond - 2/1/2019
NSC swears US policy on Israel’s nukes is legit - DOJ argues using secrecy to cover up wrongdoing is permissible - 01/15/2019
The NSC and NARA are
attempting to dismiss a
lawsuit seeking release
of the letters by
claiming the very fact
of the existence (or
nonexistence) of such
letters would inherently
be classified – and that
therefore no search for
responsive documents
need be performed. Since
FOIA courts readily
defer to agency
affidavits asserting
irreparable harm to
national security –
provided such affidavits
are specific enough –
the NSC also provided a
written justification.
Fitzgerald claimed that
confirming or denying
the existence of the
letters could result in
"sowing doubt about the
US commitment to the
Nonproliferation
Treaty…eliminating
strategic
ambiguity…revealing
information shared with
an expectation of
confidentiality;
undermining US
government policy
limiting the potential
for an arms race in a
particular
region…suggesting
differential treatment;
and revealing the
relationship (or absence
of such a relationship)
with foreign
intelligence
agencies...."
...However, citing a
dubious precedent, the
Department of Justice,
counsel to NARA in the
court battle, argued
that even if the letters
are being kept secret to
cover up wrongdoing,
such secrecy is allowed.
"There is no legal
support for the
conclusion that illegal
activities cannot
produce classified
documents…history
teaches the opposite."
The cited precedent was
the withholding of
illegal FBI surveillance
tapes of Dr. Martin
Luther King from
assassination
researchers in 1980. In
that case the DOJ
managed to win a court
order sealing the
records for an
additional fifty years
since they might
"compromise legitimate
secrecy needs."
Full report at
Antiwar.com
Lawsuit for presidential
files
Tweets by IRmep
-
|